Somewhere in New Hampshire today, a public official is going to say, “It’s already in the budget,” as though that settles the question of whose money it is.
It’s yours. Would you like to see what you bought?
Part I, Article 8 of the New Hampshire Constitution says public officials are “at all times accountable” to the people. At all times. I’m rather fond of that part. Elections come around every couple of years. The bills come in every month. In between, we have RSA 91-A, our Right-to-Know law.
Here’s why I want Free Staters using it in every town in New Hampshire:
- Freedom gets awfully local when you want to build a shed. Washington is far away, but the person who can tell you what you’re allowed to do in your own backyard probably lives within twenty minutes of your house. Zoning, assessments, school spending, police budgets. Pick the thing that made you say, “Who the hell decided that?” Now you have somewhere to start.
- You can do this in your pajamas. Yes, I have a law degree. You can send the exact same email I can. Identify the record you want. “Please provide the signed contract for the town hall roof replacement” is a perfectly respectable start. If you want a little inspiration for what happens when an ordinary person follows through, look at Laurie Ortolano in Nashua. She’s spent years digging into city records and has won Right-to-Know cases representing herself. Imagine a Laurie in every town.
- “We got a grant!” Congratulations. What did we agree to? Ask for the grant agreement. Find out who pays the match, how long the funding lasts, and whose property tax bill picks up the tab in year four. Maybe you’ll read the terms and decide it’s a good deal. Maybe year four is going to be a doozy. Either way, I’d like us to have that conversation before year four.
- Sometimes the guy who knows a guy really did submit the best bid. Great! Let’s see the bids. The same goes for the zoning variance your neighbor got after yours was denied. Pull both decisions and read the reasons side by side. Maybe there’s a perfectly sensible distinction. Maybe the distinction is who plays golf with whom. You owe it to your neighbors to find out before you start naming names.
- “We couldn’t find anything” is an answer you can follow up on. Which files did you check? Whose email did you search? What dates did you use? Under the standard discussed in ATV Watch, the question is whether the search was reasonably calculated to turn up the requested records. That distinction matters when you’re holding meeting minutes that refer to a contract the town says it can’t find. Attach the minutes. Ask again. Keep the correspondence.
- Give the next person a head start. If you went to the trouble of getting five years of police overtime figures, for the love of porcupines, put them somewhere your neighbors can find them. Include your request, the town’s response, and the date. Next March, when somebody stands up at town meeting and says, “Overtime has always been this high,” someone else can look it up. This is why I want a searchable public repository of fulfilled Right-to-Know requests. We already paid for the records. How many times should we pay to dig them out?
- Got twenty minutes and zero desire to run for office? Lovely. Take one question you’ve spent twenty minutes arguing about on Facebook and request the document that might settle it. My favorite version of this is when the document proves you wrong. Post that one, too. People remember who was willing to do that.
- Change what the next person signing the check expects. If nobody ever reads the invoices, “Who’s going to know?” is a pretty good bet. If a resident reads them every quarter and occasionally asks why the town paid the same bill twice, the incentives change. So does the conversation inside town hall the next time two identical invoices land on somebody’s desk. You can accomplish quite a bit by becoming the person everybody knows will check the math.
- Remember why we moved here. The Free State Project got people to pick up their lives and move to New Hampshire for liberty. I know what it took to get those commitments. I also know that once the moving truck leaves, you live in an actual town with an actual tax rate and a select board that meets on Tuesdays. Your neighbor who’s lived here for sixty years may have little interest in the Free State Project. She would, however, love to know why the road still floods after the town paid to fix it. There’s a project you can do together.
- Be the person who brings the invoice. Everybody remembers Erin Brockovich’s attitude. The part worth copying is the hours she spent with the files. Picture two people at the microphone on town meeting day. One says, “This project is a boondoggle.” The other says, “Voters approved $80,000. The final invoice was $112,000. Who authorized the extra $32,000?” Which question would you rather see the select board have to answer?
My ask is simple. This week, pick one thing in your town you’ve always wondered about. Ask for one record. (Find out how.) Read it. Share what you learn with the people who helped pay for it.
We moved for freedom. Now, who’s got the invoice?